| 1966* |
DE Ed Cooke, LB Tom Erlandson, CB Jimmy Warren, S Willie West |
| 1967* |
LB John Bramlett, WR Jack Clancy, QB Bob Griese, CB Dick Westmoreland |
| 1968* |
QB Bob Griese, RB Jim Kiick, WR Karl Noonan |
| 1969* |
George Wilson (coach), LB Nick Buoniconti, C Tom Goode, RB Jim Kiick, G Larry Little, DE Bill Stanfill |
| 1970 |
RB Larry Csonka, QB Bob Griese, WR Paul Warfield |
| 1971 |
RB LARRY CSONKA, QB BOB GRIESE, G Larry Little, RB Mercury Morris, S Jake Scott (dnp), DE Bill Stanfill, WR PAUL WARFIELD |
| 1972 |
S Dick Anderson, LB Nick Buoniconti (dnp), RB Larry Csonka (dnp), T Norm Evans, G LARRY LITTLE, RB Mercury Morris, S JAKE SCOTT, DE Bill Stanfill (dnp), WR Paul Warfield (dnp) |
| 1973 |
S DICK ANDERSON, LB Nick Buoniconti, RB Larry Csonka (dnp), QB Bob Griese, C JIM LANGER, G LARRY LITTLE, T Wayne Moore (dnp), RB Mercury Morris (dnp), S JAKE SCOTT, DE Bill Stanfill (dnp), WR Paul Warfield (dnp), K GARO YEPREMIAN |
| 1974 |
S DICK ANDERSON, RB Larry Csonka, T Norm Evans, QB Bob Griese, G Bob Kuechenberg, C JIM LANGER, G LARRY LITTLE, DE BILL STANFILL, S Jake Scott (dnp), WR Paul Warfield |
| 1975 |
G BOB KUECHENBERG, C JIM LANGER, S JAKE SCOTT |
| 1976 |
C JIM LANGER |
| 1977 |
QB BOB GRIESE, G Bob Kuechenberg, C JIM LANGER, WR NAT MOORE |
| 1978 |
QB Bob Griese, G Bob Kuechenberg, C Jim Langer, RB DELVIN WILLIAMS, K GARO YEPREMIAN |
| 1979 |
DT BOB BAUMHOWER, LB Kim Bokamper, S Tim Foley |
| 1980 |
NO SELECTIONS |
| 1981 |
DT BOB BAUMHOWER, G Ed Newman |
| 1982 |
DT Bob Baumhower, RB Andra Franklin, G Ed Newman (dnp), G Bob Kuechenberg1 |
| 1983 |
DT BOB BAUMHOWER, DE DOUG BETTERS, WR Mark Duper, G Bob Kuechenberg2, QB DAN MARINO (dnp), G ED NEWMAN, C DWIGHT STEPHENSON |
| 1984 |
DT Bob Baumhower (dnp), WR Mark Clayton, LB A.J. Duhe, WR MARK DUPER, QB DAN MARINO, G ED NEWMAN, P REGGIE ROBY, C DWIGHT STEPHENSON |
| 1985 |
WR Mark Clayton, G Roy Foster, QB DAN MARINO (dnp), C DWIGHT STEPHENSON |
| 1986 |
WR Mark Clayton3, WR Mark Duper (dnp), G Roy Foster, QB DAN MARINO (dnp), LB JOHN OFFERDAHL, C DWIGHT STEPHENSON (dnp) |
| 1987 |
QB Dan Marino (dnp), LB John Offerdahl, C Dwight Stephenson (dnp) |
| 1988 |
WR Mark Clayton, LB JOHN OFFERDAHL (dnp), NT Brian Sochia4 |
| 1989 |
TE Ferrell Edmunds, LB JOHN OFFERDAHL, P REGGIE ROBY |
| 1990 |
DE Jeff Cross, TE Ferrell Edmunds, LB JOHN OFFERDAHL, T Richmond Webb |
| 1991 |
WR MARK CLAYTON, QB Dan Marino (dnp), T Richmond Webb |
| 1992 |
LB BRYAN COX, TE KEITH JACKSON (dnp), QB DAN MARINO, T RICHMOND WEBB |
| 1993 |
FB Keith Byars, WR Irving Fryar5, TE Keith Jackson (dnp), G Keith Sims, T RICHMOND WEBB |
| 1994 |
LB Bryan Cox, WR Irving Fryar, QB DAN MARINO (dnp), G KEITH SIMS, T RICHMOND WEBB |
| 1995 |
LB Bryan Cox, QB DAN MARINO (dnp), G KEITH SIMS, T RICHMOND WEBB |
| 1996 |
T Richmond Webb |
| 1997 |
NO SELECTIONS |
| 1998 |
DT TIM BOWENS (dnp) |
| 1999 |
CB SAM MADISON, K OLINDO MARE, LB ZACH THOMAS6 |
| 2000 |
DE TRACE ARMSTRONG, ST Larry Izzo, CB SAM MADISON, S Brock Marion, C Tim Ruddy7, DE JASON TAYLOR, LB Zach Thomas8 |
| 2001 |
CB SAM MADISON (dnp), LB Zach Thomas (dnp) |
| 2002 |
DT Tim Bowens, CB Sam Madison9, S Brock Marion, CB PATRICK SURTAIN (dnp), DE JASON TAYLOR, LB ZACH THOMAS, RB RICKY WILLIAMS10 |
| 2003 |
DE ADEWALE OGUNLEYE, S BROCK MARION, CB PATRICK SURTAIN, LB ZACH THOMAS |
| 2004 |
DE JASON TAYLOR11, CB Patrick Surtain (dnp)12 |
| 2005 |
WR Chris Chambers, DE JASON TAYLOR (dnp), LB Zach Thomas (dnp) |
| 2006 |
DE JASON TAYLOR, LB ZACH THOMAS13 |
| 2007 |
DE Jason Taylor (dnp) |
| 2008 |
RB Ronnie Brown, T Jake Long14, LB JOEY PORTER |
| 2009 |
S Yeremiah Bell15, K Dan Carpenter16, T JAKE LONG (dnp) |
| 2010 |
LS John Denney17, T JAKE LONG (dnp), DE Randy Starks18, CAMERON WAKE |
